Skip to content

If Anyone Can Do It, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton Can

September 1, 2010

It does without saying that Secretary Clinton has demonstrated keen diplomacy skills and a commitment to ending the Arab-Israeli conflict. That said, getting Mahmoud Abbas and Benjamin Netanyahu to see eye-to-eye about anything will be not be easy, particularly given the political climate not only in the Palestinian Territories and Israel, but also here in the U.S. While many claim to support a two-state solution, they seem to do so in word only because as soon as an administration attempts to get the parties to make difficult concessions for peace, the push-back from powerful political interest groups begins. In addition, as I noted in my post below, people and groups on both sides will likely engage in activities (and rhetoric) which could serve to sabotage the peace effort.

I ran across this commentary from Dan Simpson which essentially states what I believe- Hillary Clinton is the right person at the right time to be Secretary of State during critical peace negotiations:

In any case, with the imminent commencement of Middle East peace talks, Mrs. Clinton is about to have the opportunity to construct an historic agreement, completing or at least moving forward toward an accord between the Israelis and Palestinians and the resolution of a dangerous problem that has tormented the world for more than six decades.


On the other hand, she has been most effective in getting around the world and establishing relationships with the main players in world politics, where she has been helped by her previous experiences as a senator and first lady. It was very important for her to do so.

Americans among themselves can usually get down to business quickly after meeting, even for the first time. People from other cultures, particularly in the Middle East, Africa, South Asia and East Asia, sometimes take quite a while before feeling that they have a good enough understanding of someone to talk business seriously. Mrs. Clinton was wise to take some time and travel a lot during her first 20 months on the job before undertaking anything major.

Now, even if she would have preferred not to take on the difficult task of trying to bring peace to the Middle East as her first major foreign affairs undertaking, the talks between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas will start tomorrow, preceded by a dinner tonight, and Mrs. Clinton will be ringmaster.


But Mrs. Clinton will be the one front-and-center, cajoling and twisting the arms of Mr. Abbas and Mr. Netanyahu. There will also be present at the beginning President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt and King Abdullah II of Jordan, key neighbors of the Israelis and Palestinians, both of whose countries have a dog in the fight.

During these talks Mrs. Clinton will be able to draw on all of the experience she has gained in her first 20 months as secretary of state and in her previous career as Mr. Clinton’s campaign organizer in Arkansas, as a lawyer, as first lady and as senator from New York.

This can be her finest hour to date. It is also hazardous work, a chance for her — if things were to go wrong — to suffer the diplomatic equivalent of her disastrous 1990s venture into health care reform.

Everyone — we hope — wishes her well: the people of Israel and Palestine; their neighbors in the Middle East who don’t want more wars in the region; and, most of all, Americans, who would love to step back from two countries, Israel and Palestine, that are living in security and peace with each other and not constantly importuning the United States to meet their military, political and economic needs instead of our own.

It won’t be easy, but she can do it.

8 Comments leave one →
  1. Thain permalink
    September 1, 2010 10:51 am

    Thanks for all the yesterday and today- much appreciated. U R always a great source of info. on Israel-Palestine.

    I’ll be back later!

    • Islam=Terror permalink
      September 1, 2010 10:52 am

      Yeah, she’s always a great source of pro-terror propaganda.

      Much appreciated.

  2. Steve permalink
    September 1, 2010 12:42 pm

    Good article linking to Ali Abunimah’s interview on ‘democracy now’ about Hamas and the attacks on settlers.

    It’s interesting that so many people concerned with peace and concerned with at least acknowledging that the Palestinians are also human being with actual rights (or at least they SHOULD have basic human rights) are more than willing to vehemently condemn violence perpetrated against Israelis but the hard-core pro-Israel crowd is hardly ever willing to condemn Israel or Israelis when they kill unnecessarily, murder or use excessive force. Instead all we hear is “well, Israel has to protect itself” as though that is some sort of blanket excuse for doing an end-run around a democratic process. As Stacy mentioned, Israel tends to use missiles and guns as its judge and jury. When Israel killed over 200 children in Cast Lead, there was hardly an outcry. Interesting, that.

    If people would be a little bit more even-handed then we could actually have an honest debate in this country. As an American Jew (with israeli citizenship), my community is one of the worst in terms of holding Israel to a high standard which ecompasses not only democratic ideals, but the liberal ideals which have been so much a part of Jewish life/thought/values.

  3. Tovah permalink
    September 1, 2010 12:52 pm

    Steve- I agree with you in part. But I think things are changing.

    I think with new groups like J Street and with renewed debate over how younger Jews (like myself) view Israel, we are going to see a more honest debate but AIPAC, the ADL, Dershowitz and many others will fight the change tooth and nail. They don’t want an honest debate, they want us all to have a knee-jerk reaction in defense of Israel, no matter what.

    I’m a good example of the change in view- my parents never question Israel and whenever I challenge anything they respond just as you said, by saying something like “but everyone wants to destroy Israel” or something to that effect. They know very little about the reality of the Occupation and believe that being a Good Jew means defending Israel against any criticism. I have had to try to convince them that Obama, as much as I don’t care for many of his policies, is not anti-Israel but they just believe all the rhetoric from AIPAC etc. saying otherwise.

  4. PCFS permalink
    September 1, 2010 2:53 pm

    This is going to be her legacy so keep her in all your prayers. Sen. Mitchell as well. Both the Secretary and Sen. Mitchell have been working on this since day one.
    God Speed Madame Secretary.

    • vCAL permalink
      September 1, 2010 6:55 pm

      I’m with you, only Hillary’s tenacity and hard work can do miracles; let’s pray all her effort and super hard work pay great dividends. God bless you hillary!

  5. vCAL permalink
    September 1, 2010 7:33 pm

    there’s a video of BO w/ Hillary and Mitchell in the WH on CSPAN! She’s formidable!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: